southern comfort // buttermilk pie recipe


Buttermilk Pie | The Style Scribe

Buttermilk Pie | The Style Scribe

Buttermilk Pie | The Style Scribe

Buttermilk Pie | The Style Scribe

Buttermilk Pie | The Style Scribe

For those of you who’ve been readers since the beginning, you may remember I posted this buttermilk pie recipe back in April 2012! Back then I had absolutely no skills in food photography (or presentation for that matter). I still wouldn’t say I’ve mastered it, but it’s certainly improved! Because this is still one of my favorite easy dessert recipes, I wanted to share the recipe again with better photos.

Unless you forget to put in an ingredient (like I did on my SnapChat last time!!), it really is a foolproof pie that is mouthwateringly delicious. It’s a very southern recipe that’s perfect for pairing with your favorite comfort food. I made this pie for my stepdad’s birthday at the farm, where we were having barbecue – it was a hit! I hope you all enjoy it as much as I have!

PS – since you now know about my new house… one of the first things I’m going to buy once I’m all moved in is a colorful KitchenAid mixer. The one you see above is my mom’s at her house in Austin. They are a necessity for die-hard bakers like myself. I’m thinking maybe the aqua? CUTE.


1/2 cup of butter

2 cups sugar

3 eggs

3 rounded Tbls. flour

1 cup buttermilk

1 tsp. vanilla

1 9 inch pastry crust (store bought or make your own with this recipe)


Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Cream butter and sugar in a large bowl. Add eggs and beat well. Add flour and mix well. Add buttermilk and mix well. Add vanilla and stir. Place pastry shell into a greased pie pan. Pour buttermilk mixture into pastry shell and bake 50 to 60 minutes until set. Allow to cool to room temperature before serving.


View All